One place that always deserves a stop is Pizza Man Pub in Baldwinsville. Pizza Man Pub has built a loyal following for good reason: creative specialty pizzas, solid execution, and flavors that hit every time.
Why Pizza Man Pub Is a Local Favorite
Pizza Man Pub sits right in that sweet spot between classic and creative. Their menu has familiar options for anyone who wants a traditional pie, but where they really shine is with their specialty pizzas—layered flavors, quality toppings, and combinations that just work.
For Pizza Week, I focused on three pizzas that show exactly why this place is so popular.
The Pearl: A Baldwinsville Classic
First up is The Pearl, a house favorite for a reason. This pizza features house-made sausage, roasted red peppers, and extra cheese.
The sausage brings rich, savory flavor, the roasted red peppers add sweetness, and the extra cheese ties everything together. It’s a comforting, well-balanced pizza that feels familiar but still elevated—exactly the kind of pie you order when you want something dependable and satisfying.
Sweet Heat: Bold, Spicy, and Addictive
If you’re looking for something with a little more punch, the Sweet Heat pizza delivers. This one is topped with meat cup and char pepperoni, meatballs, fresh basil, and Mike’s Hot Honey.
You get spice from the pepperoni, richness from the meatballs, freshness from the basil, and that signature sweet heat from the hot honey drizzled on top. Every bite hits differently, and it’s the kind of pizza that disappears fast once it hits the table.
The Gar-Broc-Tom: A White Pizza Standout
Rounding things out is the Gar-Broc-Tom, a white pizza topped with garlic, broccoli, and tomatoes.
This pizza proves you don’t need red sauce or heavy meats to make a great pie. The garlic brings depth, the broccoli adds texture and earthiness, and the tomatoes keep everything bright and fresh. It’s lighter than the other two but still packed with flavor—and a great option if you want something a little different.
Final Thoughts
Pizza Man Pub continues to be one of Baldwinsville’s go-to spots for a reason. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic like The Pearl, something bold like Sweet Heat, or a veggie-forward option like the Gar-Broc-Tom, there’s something here for everyone.
If you’re celebrating Pizza Week, planning a night out, or just craving a reliable, well-made pizza, Pizza Man Pub should absolutely be on your list.
👉 Follow them on Instagram
📍 50 Oswego St., Baldwinsville, NY
